Stall FAQ - FirebirdV6.com/CamaroV6.com Message Board

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Stall FAQ

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Stall FAQ

    I'm going to go ahead and copy and paste a bunch of info from other sites (who also copied and pasted it) regarding stall converters. There have been an increasing number of questions regarding them, so I think it would be beneficial for people. Mods can sticky it if they wish...

    Do I really need a tranny cooler with this stall.
    Yes. As a by product of the stalling effect, more heat is created. This heat is damaging to the tranny and the way to deal with this is to get another tranny cooler(all Fbodies came from the factory with a external tranny cooler)

    Do I need a shift kit with a high stall?
    Unlike the cooler, a shift kit is not mandatory but its a good idea. The shifts with a stall might feel a little long so when you add the shift kit, the shifts quicken just a little more than stock.

    Do I need a stall with a cam???
    Usually. Most people tune the car for the cam which involves raising the idle speed on the car. Without a stall, you will have to just stand on the brakes to keep the car still because the engine is now idleing at 800rpm. Also, a bigger cam shifts the power band of the car higher, a stall enables you to jump into the cam's powerband faster so youll be faster.

    What exactly does a high stall do?
    1) Higher RPM Launches. This is self explanitory, but so is the search button so ill explain. You can brake stall to a higher rpm and also flash stall to a higher rpm.
    2) Static Torque Ratio. I will leave the explaination of this to the experts at Yank
    "The stall torque ratio is the amount of engine torque that the torque converter can multiply at a particular rpm level. By definition, stall torque ratio is when the turbine is at 0 RPMs and the converter is at maximum designed stall. This will produce a positive push on the turbine to increase the torque to the input shaft of the transmission, multiplied by the designed stall torque ratio of the torque converter. For example, a stall torque ratio of 2.0 would multiply 200 lb. ft. of engine torque to 400 lb. ft. of torque at the transmission input-shaft. The misconception of stall torque ratio is that more must be better. This is not always the case. High stall torque ratio applications, typically are for industrial equipment or engines with limited low rpm engine torque. With high stall toque ratio converters, there are important trade-offs. What you take at one end you give up on the other. Typically, a torque converter with a very high stall torque ratio, such as 2.0-2.5, will be much less efficient above its rated stall speed. There is a sacrifice in higher rpm efficiency to achieve high stall torque ratios. That lower efficiency translates into less horsepower transmitted to the tires over an RPM range. The problem with a high stall torque ratio converter is that it is only high while the car is not moving. Maximum stall torque ratio occurs at wide open throttle with no rotation of the transmission input shaft. As the input shaft starts to rotate with vehicle forward movement, the stall torque ratio will become non-existent much sooner than a converter of the same stall, with a lower stall torque ratio." (Yank)

    3)Shift Extensions. Pretty much the rpm's wont fall down as much between shifts. This also helps deal with the dead spots between gears (like a 45mph with 3.23's).
    4)Weight- Aftermarket convertors weigh less and have less rotation mass.

    What makes some torque convertors "loose"?
    The greater the STR, the tigher the stall will be. For example a 3200rpm 2.2str stall will be looser than a 3200rpm 2.5str stall. Also, as the rpm rating increases, so does the "looseness". For example a 3600rpm 2.5str stall will be looser than a 3200rpm 2.5str stall.

    What exactly is "loose"?
    Throttle response. On a car with a loose convertor, you simply have to give it more gas to get the car moving.

    What is it like to drive a high stall?
    The best way to find out is to ask around and find someone local who will let you give their car a test drive.

    There are some videos of stalls on youtube, but from my personal experience with my 3200 stall, it feels like the trans is slipping. My car revs up to around 3500 rpm and stays there for the 1-2 shift, 2-3, and 3-4 shift...when I hit 60km/h (city cruising speed) then it locks up and drives like normal. You can change your lockup times with hp tuners, but putting it lower then stock does put more stress the car...

    What stall is the best?
    Look into 3200-3500rpm stalls for street duty. Stick with the major brands, i.e. Percision Industries (Vigilante), Yank or TCI. Remeber, you get what you pay for.

    Why do LS1's run higher stalls than LT1's???
    It is the nature of the engine. To optimize preformance, you want to match the convertor to the engines powerband. The LT1 has great bottom end power where as the LS1 has an awesome top end so a higher stall is needed on the LS1 to optimize preformance.

    Will the stall kill my tranny??
    I do not know, Im not God. It will add more stress to the internals of the tranny because of the extra power that it produces. Some people have awesome luck with thier tranny, others, not so much

    Do i need a tune??
    Maybe. Some people have issues with the car hitting the rev limiter on shifts with a stall, a tune can correct this easily. Also, for the full effect, you might want to decrease/delete the torque management.

    Will i have to rev the car to 3500rpm with my 3500rpm stall to get it to move from a stop??
    Not even close. You just have to give it alittle bit more gas than on the stock stall. I watched my tach today and saw that the revs jump to about 1200-1400rpm to get the car moving from a stop.

    Why doesnt my 3500rpm stall to brake stall to 3500rpm??
    The convertor is not broken (lets hope), its just that your brakes arent strong enough or tires not sticky enough. If you have tried this, your tires just started spinning because your brakes simply cant hold the car still. You won't be able to reach this rpm unless you have a transbrake. A transbrake locks both forward and reverse gear at the same time which allows it to rev higher and doesnt rely on the brakes or tires.

    Whats the best way to launch with a stalled auto??
    Every car is different. You just have to play around with launching it at different rpms, brake stalling it or if the tires can gripe, just stomp on the gas pedal.

    How much time will i drop??
    For me, before the stall, my best time was 12.88@109. After the stall, it turned to 12.86@107 but i was launching soft and spinning, alot. I put on a set of e/t streets, and now run 12.36 @109. So it was a nice e/t reduction. A stall will make the car faster on the track as long as you can get traction.

    Is it worth it?
    For me, yes. It greatly dropped my times at the track. Its not a mod for everyone. You will have to give it more gas to get it to move around town. If your a speed freak, youll love it.

    Should I get gears or a stall?
    Try the stall first, it will give the biggest drop in e/t's. If you still want more, change gears.

    What is the stock stall speed?
    1800 RPM

    Whats a 9.5inch stall?
    Most aftermarket stalls are 9.5inch units. The stock stall is a 12.0 inch. The 9.5 is lighter than the 12.0 so easier to rev from reduced rotational mass.
    Typical converter sizes:
    300mm = 12" (stock LS1)
    295mm = 11.5" (Stock GM)
    245mm = 9.5" (stock 6/4 cyl)
    (Thanks to 12secSS for the info)

    I bought a XXXXrpm stall made by XXX and my track times suck now, what gives?
    Most of the time, your mph will drop due to the stall being not as effecient as the factory one but if all goes right, your e.t. should drop. Check your 60ft time, more than likely your spinning the tires due to the stall transmitting large amounts of torque to the tires. To remedy this, get better tires and work on your launch. The first time you dead hook with a stall is awesome, pure and simple.

    I am at the track. Should I shift the car myself or let the car do it?
    Leave it in D or OD. You CANNOT shift faster than a computer. Some like to leave it in 3rd so it does not upshift to 4th when you let off. Others find the car shift betters in 4th if they have swapped gears (don't ask why the PCM does it)
    Last edited by LETZRIDE; 01-28-2019, 11:03 PM.

    2002 SOM Z28 Camaro - 12.9 @ 104 mph
    1996 3800 Camaro - 13.43 @ 100.77 mph


    Project Cars | How To Guides | Scratch Repair | Synthetic Oil

  • #2
    Re: Stall FAQ

    SOME INFORMATION COPIED FROM YANKS WEB SITE OF INTEREST CONCERNING STR

    Stall Torque Ratio is one of the most misunderstood aspects of torque converter construction. Our competitors often call stall torque ratio: torque multiplier. The stall torque ratio is the amount of engine torque that the torque converter can multiply at a particular rpm level. By definition, stall torque ratio is when the turbine is at 0 RPMs and the converter is at maximum designed stall. This will produce a positive push on the turbine to increase the torque to the input shaft of the transmission, multiplied by the designed stall torque ratio of the torque converter. For example, a stall torque ratio of 2.0 would multiply 200 lb. ft. of engine torque to 400 lb. ft. of torque at the transmission input-shaft.
    The misconception of stall torque ratio is that more must be better. This is not always the case. High stall torque ratio applications, typically are for industrial equipment or engines with limited low rpm engine torque. With high stall toque ratio converters, there are important trade-offs. What you take at one end you give up on the other. Typically, a torque converter with a very high stall torque ratio, such as 2.0-2.5, will be much less efficient above its rated stall speed. There is a sacrifice in higher rpm efficiency to achieve high stall torque ratios. That lower efficiency translates into less horsepower transmitted to the tires over an RPM range.

    The problem with a high stall torque ratio converter is that it is only high while the car is not moving. Maximum stall torque ratio occurs at wide open throttle with no rotation of the transmission input shaft. As the input shaft starts to rotate with vehicle forward movement, the stall torque ratio will become non-existent much sooner than a converter of the same stall, with a lower stall torque ratio. A converter with a stall torque ratio of 2.2 for example, would display that at the starting line, but it would drop off much sooner than a converter with a lower stall torque ratio. See graph:



    For example: A competitor's converter with a claimed stall torque ratio of 2.5 (red graph line) would typically have an efficiency of around 90% at high RPMs (5,000 plus). That means 300 flywheel horsepower would translate to 270 horsepower at the transmission input-shaft. A Super Yank Converter with a stall torque ratio of 1.6 (green graph line) has efficiency in the 97% range. That means a 300 horsepower engine would transmit 291 horsepower to the transmission input-shaft: A gain of 21 horsepower!

    As you can see, the converter with the lower stall torque ratio will multiply torque for a longer period of time than the converter with a higher stall torque ratio. As most of you know, most racing occurs above 3,000 RPMs. That's why the lower stall torque ratio often wins the race:

    *Lower stall torque ratio is gentler on the tires at the initial launch, but it will pull harder for the remaining 1,305 ft. of the 1/4 mile. Less races will be lost at the starting line from excessive wheelspin.
    Lower stall torque ratio will be more efficient and transmit more torque and horsepower to the tires. This translates into lower ETs and higher trap speeds

    2002 SOM Z28 Camaro - 12.9 @ 104 mph
    1996 3800 Camaro - 13.43 @ 100.77 mph


    Project Cars | How To Guides | Scratch Repair | Synthetic Oil

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Stall FAQ

      Nice info please Stickey this mods.
      08' L76 6.0L 4X4 Chevy EXT.Cab LTZ Vortec MAX with Snug top cover, Dynomax exhaust,Hptuners& K&N intake
      96' Camaro M5 to A4 conversion, alot of mods . GT35R Turbo full suspension. Built engine

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Stall FAQ

        Also if anyone is confused "Stall" is slang for Torque Converters. Torque Converters have stall ratings/ratios and so it seems to be easier for some people to call them "Stalls"

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Stall FAQ

          Can we use the same converters that fit the LS1 cars? I am looking at the converters on summit and I just put in 4L60E. Will any of those fit?

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Stall FAQ

            as far as I know, no...shaft size is different. You can use one from an S10, but it is just a looser stock converter, it doesn't have the same benefits of a real stall converter with the shift extension etc...

            2002 SOM Z28 Camaro - 12.9 @ 104 mph
            1996 3800 Camaro - 13.43 @ 100.77 mph


            Project Cars | How To Guides | Scratch Repair | Synthetic Oil

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Stall FAQ

              Originally posted by LETZRIDE View Post
              as far as I know, no...shaft size is different. You can use one from an S10, but it is just a looser stock converter, it doesn't have the same benefits of a real stall converter with the shift extension etc...
              So we are screwed? So we cant just use any 4L60E converter? I have no clue where to look then.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Stall FAQ

                You're really dramatic aren't you?

                http://www.abbottracingheads.com/gm3800.htm

                looks like performabuilt is no longer manufacturing their own converters, so you may want to contact them about which of their vendor's converters works in the 3800

                http://www.performabuilt.com/converternew.html

                2002 SOM Z28 Camaro - 12.9 @ 104 mph
                1996 3800 Camaro - 13.43 @ 100.77 mph


                Project Cars | How To Guides | Scratch Repair | Synthetic Oil

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Stall FAQ

                  Originally posted by LETZRIDE View Post
                  You can use one from an S10, but it is just a looser stock converter, it doesn't have the same benefits of a real stall converter with the shift extension etc...
                  Yes it does. The aftermarket converters are just stronger.
                  sigpic

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Stall FAQ

                    Originally posted by bigbrian442 View Post
                    Yes it does. The aftermarket converters are just stronger.
                    The S10 converters do not have the added shift extensions of the aftermarket units- you will fall below 5000rpm inbetween shifts.

                    They also have a lower STR than the aftermarket units which are typically 2.xx unless you specify you want otherwise.

                    2002 SOM Z28 Camaro - 12.9 @ 104 mph
                    1996 3800 Camaro - 13.43 @ 100.77 mph


                    Project Cars | How To Guides | Scratch Repair | Synthetic Oil

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Stall FAQ

                      Originally posted by LETZRIDE View Post
                      The S10 converters do not have the added shift extensions of the aftermarket units- you will fall below 5000rpm inbetween shifts.

                      They also have a lower STR than the aftermarket units which are typically 2.xx unless you specify you want otherwise.

                      There is one converter manufacturer that puts STR as a reason to buy there converter. The bottom line is the higher the converter stalls the higher the STR is. The S10 converter will give you the shift extentions the same as an aftermarket stall. They are also dependent on how high the converter stalls.

                      Unless your buying a $1000+ stall for your V 6, your getting a furnace brazed, restalled S10 converter with 90% stock componets from any converter builder.
                      sigpic

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Stall FAQ

                        Okay so I will look at those. Does anyone know the difference, besides the bell housing, between the 4L60E used in the LS1 vs the 3800?

                        Comment

                        Latest Topics

                        Collapse

                        • Andy H
                          Hello everyone!
                          by Andy H
                          Its been a while since I've been on the forum. Hope everyone is doing well. I still have my camaro! Unfortunately, the slave cylinder and clutch has went...
                          3 weeks ago
                        • 3.4 slow to go
                          hey there strangers!
                          by 3.4 slow to go
                          been a while but looks like i'm back in the game thanks to my brother. he went and bought an'02 bird, and since i'm a technician at the nissan place...
                          3 weeks ago

                        FORUM SPONSORS

                        Collapse
                        Working...
                        X